Tea with the Queen

How To Build A Waitlist People Actually Want To Join

Watch

Listen

Building a waitlist starts long before you create a waitlist page. It starts months earlier with demand, reputation, and a clear offer people can picture themselves in. Here’s how to build a waitlist full of people who actually want what you sell, rather than a list of mildly interested names who forget why they signed up.

A lot of business owners build waitlists backwards. They put up a page that says “join the waitlist” and then they wait. That’s not a strategy. That’s hope with a landing page.

If you want a waitlist that actually works, stop thinking of it as a status symbol and start treating it like what it is. A waitlist is the outcome of demand. It’s a group of people saying “me next”.

A real waitlist is full of people who know what they’re waiting for, why they joined, and what happens next.

A dead waitlist is a spreadsheet of mildly interested people who forgot why they put their name down, and when you email them three months later, they’re thinking, who even are you?

The goal isn’t “more names”. The goal is more of the right people, with a clear reason to stay close.

1) Have Something Worth Waiting For

This sounds obvious, but it matters. A waitlist doesn’t create demand. Demand creates the waitlist.

You can’t manufacture scarcity around something nobody particularly wants. If you’re constantly trying to convince people why they should buy the thing, adding a waitlist doesn’t suddenly make it irresistible.

Before you build the waitlist, look at the offer.

Is it clear? Is the outcome clear? Do people understand who it’s for? Have people bought it before? Do they talk about it? Do they recommend it? Can people see themselves in it?

“Join the waitlist” isn’t an offer. The thing on the other side of the waitlist is the offer.

2) Build Demand Before You’re Sold Out

Don’t wait until you’re sold out to start thinking about demand.

When we run an event, a launch, or something new, we nearly always start with a giveaway. Generosity is one of our core values, and it creates energy before we ask people to buy. It makes it fun, it gets people talking, and then we sell.

That’s the point. The waitlist starts long before the waitlist page. It starts with the reputation you build around the offer.

3) Make The Waitlist Specific

Please don’t have one giant button on your website that says “join my waitlist” with no context.

Join the waitlist for what, when, why, who? What happens next?

A good waitlist has a reason to exist. For Day With The Queen, it’s simple. We sold out. If a ticket becomes available, waitlisters get the first opportunity to take that place.

If you’re building a waitlist for a programme, a day, or a service, tell people exactly what they’re waiting for. Don’t make people decipher what they signed up for.

4) Give People A Reason To Join

“Join the waitlist” isn’t compelling on its own.

Why should someone give you their email address? What advantage do they get?

Maybe they get first access. Maybe they get 24 hours before everyone else. Maybe they get the first opportunity to book a call. Maybe there’s a waitlist-only bonus.

Whatever it is, there needs to be value in raising your hand early.

5) Keep Talking To Your Waitlist

This is the part so many people miss.

Someone joins your waitlist, and then three months later they get an email saying “we’re open” and they’re scratching their head thinking, what did I sign up for?

You can’t put people in a digital cupboard and pull them out when you need money.

Keep nurturing them. Show them what’s happening behind the scenes. Share stories and results. Give them useful content. Build desire while they wait.

The waitlist isn’t where marketing stops. It’s where a different kind of marketing begins.

6) Make Joining Easy

Don’t ask for someone’s life story to join a waitlist.

Name and email, maybe one useful question. Reduce friction. Every extra field is another moment where someone thinks, I’ll do it later.

And we all know what later means.

7) Decide The Process Before You Need It

If a spot opens, what happens?

Do you email everyone? Do you contact the first person? Do they have 24 hours? Is it first come, first served? Do they need to pay immediately?

Decide the process while you’re calm, so when the opportunity appears, you run the system.

Humanise the front, systematise the back.

8) Your Sold Out Offer Is Marketing For The Next One

A sold out event, a full program, or a booked out service is evidence.

It tells you the offer worked. The messaging worked. The timing worked.

So don’t disappear. Keep telling the story. Share the behind the scenes. Let people see what they missed, in a way that invites them closer next time.

You can build a waitlist before you launch. Expressions of interest let you talk to real humans early, test your messaging, and build anticipation so you’re not launching to a cold audience.

If you want a waitlist, don’t start by asking “how do I get more names?” Ask “how do I create something people don’t want to miss?” Then tell people about it, invite them in, sell it, and when it sells out, make it easy for the people who missed out to say, me next.

Read The Full Transcript

EMMA: [00:00:00] A wait list doesn't start on a wait list page. It starts months earlier with demand, reputation, and a clear offer people can picture themselves in. Today we're talking about something that every business owner says they want a wait list because doesn't it sound fabulous or sorry, we are sold out. You have to join the wait list.
Very fancy, but I don't wanna talk about wait lists as some kind of status simple. I wanna talk about how you actually build one and more importantly, how you build a wait list full of people who actually want what you sell, rather than a spreadsheet full of mildly interested people who have forgotten why they even put their name down.
We've all been there because there is a difference, and I've got a very, very current example. Let's talk David the Queen. Yeah. Whenever we run a event, a launch, or something new, or we have a programme to sell, we nearly always start the campaign with a giveaway. [00:01:00] Why you ask? Because generosity is one of our core values here at Emma McQueen, P-T-Y-L-T-D.
I like starting with giving. Before we ask people to buy, we create some energy, we give people an opportunity to participate. We make it fun. We get people talking about whatever the thing is, and then we sell. Now, normally our selling period will run for about six weeks. That's the rhythm. This year we did exactly that for Day with the Queen.
We kicked it off with a giveaway across our social channels and our email list, and then, then we started selling. Except our six week sales campaign didn't quite go according to plan because three weeks in, we sold out 140 women in the room in October, done and dusted, which is of course a fantastic problem to have.
I'm not complaining, but here's the thing. We also know [00:02:00] that life happens. People get sick, work changes, family things happen. Plans change. Someone who absolutely intended to be there suddenly can't be there. And I also know there are women who missed out, who would've loved to have been in that room. So we built a wait list, and that got me thinking about wait lists in general, because I reckon a lot of business owners build them backwards.
They kind of think, I'll put up a page saying, join the wait list, and then they wait. And that's not really a strategy. So today I want to talk about how to build a wait list that actually works. I think I've nailed about eight things. Let's see. Feel free to count along as you go first. You need something worth waiting for.
Now, I know this might sound incredibly obvious, but I need to say it. A wait list itself does not create demand. Demand creates the wait list. You can't [00:03:00] manufacture scarcity around something nobody particularly wants. If you can let me know what you do, if you're constantly trying to convince people why they should buy the thing, adding a wait list isn't going to suddenly make it irresistible.
But before you even worry about the wait list, worry about the offer. Is it clear? Is the outcome clear? Do people actually understand who it's for? You've heard all this before. Have people bought it before? Do people talk about it? All the things? Do they recommend it? Can people see themselves in it?
Because join the wait list, that's actually not an offer. The thing on the other side of that wait list, that's the offer. Yeah. Secondly, don't wait until you're sold out. To start thinking about demand, this is where our giveaway comes in. We didn't wake up after selling 140 tickets and suddenly start trying to find more people.
We'd been building demand all along. The [00:04:00] giveaway was part of that. The emails were also part of that. Our socials, Beck does an amazing job of that. And all of the conversations were part of that. The direct invitations were part of that. The stories from previous events, the socials from previous events, and your wait list starts long before you create the wait list page.
It starts with the reputation you build around whatever the offer is. I want people to see Day with the queen happening and think next time I'm going, we only do this every two years. That is wait list marketing, right? Third, make the wait list specific. Please don't have one giant button on your website that says, join my wait list for what, when, why, who?
What happens next? You see, a good wait list has a reason to exist for day with the Queen. It's incredibly, incredibly simple. We are sold out. There are 140 women coming. If a ticket becomes available, the [00:05:00] people on the wait list get an opportunity to take that place. Pretty clear, right? Very specific and that that clarity that really matters.
If you're building a wait list for a programme, if you're building a wait list for a day, if you're building a wait list for an offer, tell people what they're waiting for. If your opening enrollments in February, tell them if there are only 20 places, tell them. Don't make people decipher what they've actually signed up for.
Fourth, give people a reason to join. Now, this is the bit I see that people miss join. The wait list isn't particularly compelling on its own, right? Why should I? Why would I want to give my email address away? What advantage does it give me? Being on the wait list? Maybe they get first access. Maybe they get 24 hours before everyone else.
Maybe they get the first opportunity to book a call. Maybe there's a wait list, only bonus, or they get a special invitation to something for a day with the queen, they're first in line If a ticket becomes [00:06:00] available, that's it. There needs to be some value in raising your hand early and saying, put me on the wait list.
I need to say this. Don't create fake scarcity. Don't tell people there are three places left when there are 30. Don't do that. Don't say something is selling out when it isn't. Don't manufacture urgency because you think that's what marketing is. It's not. People aren't stupid. Real demand is powerful enough.
And actually, day with the queen, it gave me the perfect example of this. When we got down to 17 tickets, I jumped on socials and told people, that's it. 17 tickets left. No fancy sales strategy, no manufactured numbers or urgency. Literally we have 17 tickets left. Two days later we were down to three tickets.
So I jumped back on socials and told everyone again, we have three tickets left. And then nine people bought tickets. [00:07:00] Nine. I know my, apparently I don't do maths that well. My maths wasn't math thing. And so we had 120 places originally in the room and somehow sold 146 tickets, which thankfully we could accommodate.
But Reena may never let me near ticket numbers again. But this is what I'm here to tell you. People need information to make decisions. There were women sitting there thinking about coming. They hadn't said no, they just hadn't made the purchasing decision yet, right? So when I said 17 tickets were left out of 120 originally, some of them just went bang, made a decision.
And when I said there was only three left, nine of them went bang. Before I could change the website numbers, I didn't need to create any kind of urgency. The urgency was real. I just needed to make sure that I could communicate it. And I think sometimes business owners feel a little bit uncomfortable doing this because they worry that they'll sound salesy.
Who cares? But telling someone the truth is [00:08:00] not being salesy. If there are 17 tickets left, you tell them, if there are three places left, tell them if applications close a Friday, tell them if your diary is booked until November, until December until the new year, tell 'em don't manufacture scarcity. But equally, don't hide real scarcity because you're frightened.
Someone might think that you are like selling or worse bragging 'cause you are selling and people can't make a decision based on information you haven't given them. Yeah, in our case, perhaps give them slightly more accurate information than I did. But you get my drift, right? You get my drift. Number five, keep talking to the people on your wait list.
This one's massive. Someone joins a wait list. Three months later they receive an email. We're open and they're like scratching their head thinking, who even are you? What did I sign up for? Got no [00:09:00] idea. Why am I even here? You can't put people in a digital cupboard and then pull them out when you need money, and that's not how this works.
You still gotta nurture them. You still gotta show them what's happening behind the scenes. Share stories, share results. We kept doing this. Give them useful content. David the Queen. We keep doing that. Let them have a little peek behind the scenes. Build the desire while they wait. If it is an event or you know, show them the room or the speakers or the preparation.
We've done lives, we've done all the things. We've had conversations. If it's a programme, show them what current clients are doing. If it's one-on-one coaching for me. Let them understand how you work and what your clients are actually achieving. Show some results. Show some social proof. The wait list isn't where marketing stops.
It's where a different kind of marketing begins. Sixth, make joining incredibly easy. Please don't ask me for my life story to join a wait list, name, email, maybe one useful qualifying [00:10:00] question. And if you're me, a phone number done, you are not marrying them. You're asking whether they'd like to hear when something becomes available.
Reduce the friction because every necessary field is another opportunity for someone to think. Yeah. Nah. Too hard. I'll do it later. And we all know what later means. Later means never. It really means never. Seventh. Know what you're going to do when a spot opens. Sounds obvious, right? But this is really important.
When the available is unpredictable. Let's say someone cancels their day with the queen, they're like, sick, whatever. What happens? Do you email all 50 people on the wait list? Do you contact the first person on your wait list? Does the first person have 24 hours? Does it go first, come first served? Does someone need to pay immediately to secure it?
Decide the process before you actually need the process. Because when a place [00:11:00] becomes available, you don't want your team sitting around going, what do we do now? Who do we give it to? What does it look like? You gotta build the system while you're calm. Then when the opportunity appears, you simply run the system.
We wanna humanise the front and systematise the backend. You knew I was gonna say that, right? I love that. Number eight, our final one, I think your sold out offer is marketing for the next one. I reckon this is probably the biggest opportunity of all. We now have 140 women coming today with a queen and a wait list of 40.
That isn't just an event, that's evidence. It tells us something. The market wanted this so badly. The messaging worked, the timing worked, the offer worked. People wanted to be in that room. So I don't wanna throw all of that momentum away. The moment we put out the sold out sign, we wanna capture it because someone saying, sold [00:12:00] out today might be the first person buying next time.
And if you have a sold out event or a full programme or a booked out service, don't disappear. Keep telling the story. The behind the scenes, let people see what they missed. Not in a horrible, you should have bought way, although feel free, but more in a, this is what we're creating and if you'd like to be part of it next time, come closer kind of way.
And there's one more kind of wait list. The wait list you build before you launch. And this is where things get really interesting. You don't need to wait until something sells out to use a wait list. If you are developing a new offer, say thriving women, you can start gathering expressions of interest way before it launches.
We do it a year in advance, and I love that, right? Because instead of spending three months secretly ferreting behind the scenes, creating [00:13:00] something, and then popping up one Tuesday and going, ta-da. Bye bye thing. You've actually already got people with their hands up. You can talk to them, ask questions, understand what they want, test your messaging, test your thinking, build anticipation.
And when you are ready to sell, you're not launching to a cold audience. Yes, you're opening the doors to people who have already told you I'm interested. That is completely different sales conversation, right? So how do you actually build your wait list? Practicality. Here's your homework. I want you to answer five questions for me.
One, what exactly are people waiting for? Not my programme. Be really specific. Number two, why would someone want to join the wait list? Now what's in it for them? Number three, where are you going to invite people onto? Is it an email? Is it socials? Is [00:14:00] it a podcast? Is it your website? Is it in conversations or an event?
You know, hopefully more than one of those. Number four, what are you going to do with them while they wait? How will you stay useful and relevant? And number five, what happens when a place becomes available or doors open? Know the process. That's it. It doesn't need to be complicated. The simpler the better.
And one final thing, I think sometimes business owners look at a wait list and they think. Gosh, I'd love to have one of those. But they're looking at the end result. They're seeing the sold out sign. They see the names on the list, they see people wanting in. What they don't see is everything that happened before it to get to that point, all the emails that were sent, social posts, the conversations, the years of delivering the thing, well, like Day with the [00:15:00] Queen we're in third round.
They don't see the generosity or the reputation or the invitations or the asking, the selling the following up for Day With the Queen, we plan to sell for six weeks, and we sold out in three. We told people when there were 17 tickets left, don't sit on the fence, you're gonna miss out. We told them again when there were three tickets left, and apparently nine people took that as their cue to buy, and now we have a wait list for anyone else who wants to be in that room.
If life happens and a ticket becomes available, and I feel like that's fabulous, but none of it happened because we whacked a ticket page on the internet and crossed our fingers and used hope as a strategy. The wait list is the outcome of demand. So if you wanna wait list, don't start by asking, how do I get more names onto a list?
Ask a better question. How do I create something people don't want to miss? Then tell people [00:16:00] about it. Invite them in, sell it. Tell them when it's filling. Tell them when it's nearly full. Tell 'em. Tell 'em. Tell 'em. And when it does sell out, make it incredibly easy for the people who missed out to say me next, because that's really, that's really what a great wait list is.
It's a group of people saying me next, and I reckon that's exactly what we're all aiming for. I look forward to seeing you next time. Thanks for listening to Tea with the Queen. If you've enjoyed this podcast, please leave a rating and review on Apple Podcasts. It really does help. To get the word out for more about me, please visit emma mcqueen.com au and I look forward to your company next episode.