Building a waitlist starts long before you create a waitlist page. It starts months earlier with demand, reputation, and a clear offer people can picture themselves in. Here’s how to build a waitlist full of people who actually want what you sell, rather than a list of mildly interested names who forget why they signed up.
A lot of business owners build waitlists backwards. They put up a page that says “join the waitlist” and then they wait. That’s not a strategy. That’s hope with a landing page.
If you want a waitlist that actually works, stop thinking of it as a status symbol and start treating it like what it is. A waitlist is the outcome of demand. It’s a group of people saying “me next”.
A real waitlist is full of people who know what they’re waiting for, why they joined, and what happens next.
A dead waitlist is a spreadsheet of mildly interested people who forgot why they put their name down, and when you email them three months later, they’re thinking, who even are you?
The goal isn’t “more names”. The goal is more of the right people, with a clear reason to stay close.
1) Have Something Worth Waiting For
This sounds obvious, but it matters. A waitlist doesn’t create demand. Demand creates the waitlist.
You can’t manufacture scarcity around something nobody particularly wants. If you’re constantly trying to convince people why they should buy the thing, adding a waitlist doesn’t suddenly make it irresistible.
Before you build the waitlist, look at the offer.
Is it clear? Is the outcome clear? Do people understand who it’s for? Have people bought it before? Do they talk about it? Do they recommend it? Can people see themselves in it?
“Join the waitlist” isn’t an offer. The thing on the other side of the waitlist is the offer.
2) Build Demand Before You’re Sold Out
Don’t wait until you’re sold out to start thinking about demand.
When we run an event, a launch, or something new, we nearly always start with a giveaway. Generosity is one of our core values, and it creates energy before we ask people to buy. It makes it fun, it gets people talking, and then we sell.
That’s the point. The waitlist starts long before the waitlist page. It starts with the reputation you build around the offer.
3) Make The Waitlist Specific
Please don’t have one giant button on your website that says “join my waitlist” with no context.
Join the waitlist for what, when, why, who? What happens next?
A good waitlist has a reason to exist. For Day With The Queen, it’s simple. We sold out. If a ticket becomes available, waitlisters get the first opportunity to take that place.
If you’re building a waitlist for a programme, a day, or a service, tell people exactly what they’re waiting for. Don’t make people decipher what they signed up for.
4) Give People A Reason To Join
“Join the waitlist” isn’t compelling on its own.
Why should someone give you their email address? What advantage do they get?
Maybe they get first access. Maybe they get 24 hours before everyone else. Maybe they get the first opportunity to book a call. Maybe there’s a waitlist-only bonus.
Whatever it is, there needs to be value in raising your hand early.
5) Keep Talking To Your Waitlist
This is the part so many people miss.
Someone joins your waitlist, and then three months later they get an email saying “we’re open” and they’re scratching their head thinking, what did I sign up for?
You can’t put people in a digital cupboard and pull them out when you need money.
Keep nurturing them. Show them what’s happening behind the scenes. Share stories and results. Give them useful content. Build desire while they wait.
The waitlist isn’t where marketing stops. It’s where a different kind of marketing begins.
6) Make Joining Easy
Don’t ask for someone’s life story to join a waitlist.
Name and email, maybe one useful question. Reduce friction. Every extra field is another moment where someone thinks, I’ll do it later.
And we all know what later means.
7) Decide The Process Before You Need It
If a spot opens, what happens?
Do you email everyone? Do you contact the first person? Do they have 24 hours? Is it first come, first served? Do they need to pay immediately?
Decide the process while you’re calm, so when the opportunity appears, you run the system.
Humanise the front, systematise the back.
8) Your Sold Out Offer Is Marketing For The Next One
A sold out event, a full program, or a booked out service is evidence.
It tells you the offer worked. The messaging worked. The timing worked.
So don’t disappear. Keep telling the story. Share the behind the scenes. Let people see what they missed, in a way that invites them closer next time.
You can build a waitlist before you launch. Expressions of interest let you talk to real humans early, test your messaging, and build anticipation so you’re not launching to a cold audience.
If you want a waitlist, don’t start by asking “how do I get more names?” Ask “how do I create something people don’t want to miss?” Then tell people about it, invite them in, sell it, and when it sells out, make it easy for the people who missed out to say, me next.