I’m going to ruffle a few feathers, because I keep hearing this line in the business coaching world: “I only want a coach who’s run the exact same type of business as mine.” I get it. You want someone who speaks your industry language and understands the day-to-day reality.
But do you want someone who knows how your industry has always worked, or someone who can help you build something that works better? Sometimes the coach who has lived inside the industry for years is also carrying the same assumptions you’re trying to outgrow. Industry experience can be valuable, but it isn’t the same thing as coaching skill and it’s worth separating the two.
The Ceiling You Didn’t Know You’d Agreed To
Let me tell you a story, with a few details changed to protect a beautiful client.
I’ve worked with a business owner for about five years. When we started, the business was losing money, so we did the unsexy work: pricing, costs, delivery, efficiency, and the numbers that decide whether a business is actually viable. Over time, we turned it around and started setting bigger goals.
Here’s what mattered. People in her industry had a very clear view of what “good profit” looked like, and it came with an unofficial ceiling. I didn’t have that ceiling in my head, because I hadn’t grown up in that industry. I was simply looking at the business and asking what would need to change to make it more profitable, then helping her make those changes. It made me wonder how often we accept limits just because they’re familiar.
Running A Business And Coaching A Business Are Not The Same Skill
There’s a common assumption that if someone has run a certain type of business, they must be the best person to coach others in that same business. Sometimes that’s true, but it’s not automatic.
Coaching is its own skill. It’s about helping someone think, decide and follow through, especially when the work is uncomfortable. I’ve spent more than 20 years in HR and leadership and I’ve built my own business, but I haven’t run every type of business my clients operate. What I do understand is how businesses work, how people behave under pressure and how commercial discipline changes outcomes.
The Risk Of Staying Inside The Industry Echo Chamber
When you only learn from people inside your industry, you can end up with a narrow view of what’s possible. Not always, but often enough that it’s worth watching.
If you’re a lawyer, for example, you’ll hear a lot about billable hours and utilisation. Useful, but your biggest opportunity might be in your offer design, client mix, pricing model or building a practice that doesn’t rely on you for every dollar. If you run a marketing agency, the default advice is often “more clients, more staff,” when the real issue might be pricing, scope creep or a service that’s too broad to deliver profitably. An outside perspective can surface options that the industry conversation has normalised away.
Ask A Better Question When You’re Choosing A Coach
Instead of “Have you run a business exactly like mine?” try “Have you helped business owners solve the problems I’m facing?”
If you need profitability, you need someone who understands profitability. If you need leadership, you need someone who can build leaders and teams. If you need business development, you need someone who understands how opportunities are created and converted. The coach’s exact industry background might be a bonus, but it shouldn’t be the whole screening process.
What A Great Coach Actually Does
A great coach helps you see what you’re too close to notice, and they bring you back to what’s real. That means decisions, evidence, and follow-through, not assumptions and stories.
Business owners are often very good at explaining why something won’t work, and sometimes they’re right. Other times it’s a habit that’s been repeated so often it sounds like truth. A good coach will calmly ask you to look at the numbers, the behaviour and the results you’re getting, then help you change what needs changing.
Transferable Expertise Is Real
I don’t need to be the smartest person in the room about my client’s technical profession. I want them to be brilliant at what they do. My role is to bring commercial skill, leadership skill, and business development skill, alongside their industry expertise.
Working across industries also means I see patterns, and I can test ideas that have worked elsewhere without being tied to “the way it’s always been done.” That said, good coaching includes knowing the edges of your expertise. If something is legal, clinical, technical or regulatory, you bring in the right specialist. The goal is the right outcome, not one person pretending to know everything.
Don’t Confuse Familiarity With Capability
If you’re looking for a business coach, don’t dismiss someone just because they haven’t walked your exact path. The person who’s walked your path might show you how to stay on it, and the person who’s walked a different one might show you an option you didn’t know existed.
So if you’re sitting there thinking, “In my industry, we can only make this much profit,” I’ll leave you with one question: who told you that was your ceiling, and what if they’re wrong?
RESOURCES:
LinkedIn: https://tea-with-the-queen.captivate.fm/linkedin
Emma’s New Book “Selling Without the Ick”:
https://emmamcqueen.com.au/want-more/selling-without-the-ick
For a copy of Emma’s book, ‘Go-getter: Raise your mojo, shift your mindset and thrive’ – https://emmamcqueen.com.au/want-more/emmas-book/
BD Sprint: