Tea with the Queen

The Best Business Coach Might Not Be In Your Industry

Watch

Listen

I’m going to ruffle a few feathers, because I keep hearing this line in the business coaching world: “I only want a coach who’s run the exact same type of business as mine.” I get it. You want someone who speaks your industry language and understands the day-to-day reality.

But do you want someone who knows how your industry has always worked, or someone who can help you build something that works better? Sometimes the coach who has lived inside the industry for years is also carrying the same assumptions you’re trying to outgrow. Industry experience can be valuable, but it isn’t the same thing as coaching skill and it’s worth separating the two.

The Ceiling You Didn’t Know You’d Agreed To

Let me tell you a story, with a few details changed to protect a beautiful client.

I’ve worked with a business owner for about five years. When we started, the business was losing money, so we did the unsexy work: pricing, costs, delivery, efficiency, and the numbers that decide whether a business is actually viable. Over time, we turned it around and started setting bigger goals.

Here’s what mattered. People in her industry had a very clear view of what “good profit” looked like, and it came with an unofficial ceiling. I didn’t have that ceiling in my head, because I hadn’t grown up in that industry. I was simply looking at the business and asking what would need to change to make it more profitable, then helping her make those changes. It made me wonder how often we accept limits just because they’re familiar.

Running A Business And Coaching A Business Are Not The Same Skill

There’s a common assumption that if someone has run a certain type of business, they must be the best person to coach others in that same business. Sometimes that’s true, but it’s not automatic.

Coaching is its own skill. It’s about helping someone think, decide and follow through, especially when the work is uncomfortable. I’ve spent more than 20 years in HR and leadership and I’ve built my own business, but I haven’t run every type of business my clients operate. What I do understand is how businesses work, how people behave under pressure and how commercial discipline changes outcomes.

The Risk Of Staying Inside The Industry Echo Chamber

When you only learn from people inside your industry, you can end up with a narrow view of what’s possible. Not always, but often enough that it’s worth watching.

If you’re a lawyer, for example, you’ll hear a lot about billable hours and utilisation. Useful, but your biggest opportunity might be in your offer design, client mix, pricing model or building a practice that doesn’t rely on you for every dollar. If you run a marketing agency, the default advice is often “more clients, more staff,” when the real issue might be pricing, scope creep or a service that’s too broad to deliver profitably. An outside perspective can surface options that the industry conversation has normalised away.

Ask A Better Question When You’re Choosing A Coach

Instead of “Have you run a business exactly like mine?” try “Have you helped business owners solve the problems I’m facing?”

If you need profitability, you need someone who understands profitability. If you need leadership, you need someone who can build leaders and teams. If you need business development, you need someone who understands how opportunities are created and converted. The coach’s exact industry background might be a bonus, but it shouldn’t be the whole screening process.

What A Great Coach Actually Does

A great coach helps you see what you’re too close to notice, and they bring you back to what’s real. That means decisions, evidence, and follow-through, not assumptions and stories.

Business owners are often very good at explaining why something won’t work, and sometimes they’re right. Other times it’s a habit that’s been repeated so often it sounds like truth. A good coach will calmly ask you to look at the numbers, the behaviour and the results you’re getting, then help you change what needs changing.

Transferable Expertise Is Real

I don’t need to be the smartest person in the room about my client’s technical profession. I want them to be brilliant at what they do. My role is to bring commercial skill, leadership skill, and business development skill, alongside their industry expertise.

Working across industries also means I see patterns, and I can test ideas that have worked elsewhere without being tied to “the way it’s always been done.” That said, good coaching includes knowing the edges of your expertise. If something is legal, clinical, technical or regulatory, you bring in the right specialist. The goal is the right outcome, not one person pretending to know everything.

Don’t Confuse Familiarity With Capability

If you’re looking for a business coach, don’t dismiss someone just because they haven’t walked your exact path. The person who’s walked your path might show you how to stay on it, and the person who’s walked a different one might show you an option you didn’t know existed.

So if you’re sitting there thinking, “In my industry, we can only make this much profit,” I’ll leave you with one question: who told you that was your ceiling, and what if they’re wrong?


RESOURCES:

LinkedIn: https://tea-with-the-queen.captivate.fm/linkedin 

Emma’s New Book “Selling Without the Ick”:

https://emmamcqueen.com.au/want-more/selling-without-the-ick

For a copy of Emma’s book, ‘Go-getter: Raise your mojo, shift your mindset and thrive’ – https://emmamcqueen.com.au/want-more/emmas-book/

YouTube Channel

BD Sprint:

https://emmamcqueen.com.au/coaching-services/bd-sprint

Read The Full Transcript

[00:00:00] EMMA: WHO TOLD YOU THAT WAS YOUR CEILING? that's the name of this situation. I'm going to ruffle a few feathers today, not deliberately, well, perhaps a little bit deliberately, because I want to challenge something I hear really regularly in the business coaching world.
[00:00:14] And it's this:
[00:00:15] "I only wanna work with a coach who's run the EXACT same type of business as mine."
[00:00:20] Really? Why? Now, I do kind of understand the thinking. You want someone who understands your industry, someone who knows the challenges, speaks the language, and also understands the
[00:00:35] peculiarities of running your particular business.
[00:00:39] Fair enough. I get that. But here's my question: Do you want someone who understands how your industry has always operated,
[00:00:48] or someone who can help you see how your business could operate differently? Because those are not necessarily the same person. I hate to say it. And sometimes the person who has run exactly the same type of business as you might be the very person who reinforces
[00:01:05] the limitations that you're trying to escape.
[00:01:08] Now, before anyone gets their knickers in a knot, I'm not suggesting industry experience is worthless. Far from it. But I am suggesting that sometimes industry experience and business coaching expertise are two different things, can be two different things. And I think we need to stop, like, confusing them a bit.
[00:01:29] I wanna tell you a story. You know I love a story. But in this one, I'm gonna change some details to protect my beautiful client that is involved, but the business lesson is very real. I have been working with a business owner for quite some time, I would say five years. When we first started working together, the business was not making a profit.
[00:01:50] In fact, it was losing money, and over time, through consistent work, we turned that around. We looked at the numbers. [00:02:00] We crunched the numbers. We looked at the business model. We crunched that. We looked at pricing. We looked at
[00:02:05] delivery
[00:02:06] costs
[00:02:07] efficiency
[00:02:07] and all the things that make a business commercially viable.
[00:02:11] And then we got into the black, and then we improved the profit. And then we started setting some really ambitious goals. Now, here's the interesting bit. This client spends time, a lot of time, with other people in her industry, and those people had a very clear opinion about how much profit a business like hers could make.
[00:02:34] There was this accepted ceiling, an unofficial number that everyone seemed to agree was about as good as it got. And I remember thinking to myself, " Says who?" Because I hadn't come from that industry. I didn't have that ceiling in my head. I wasn't carrying years of conversations about what was supposedly possible.
[00:03:00] I was looking at a business and asking,
[00:03:02] "How do we make this more profitable?" And we made progress beyond what she'd been told to expect. Wasn't magic, and it certainly wasn't manifesting money, but by making different decisions, working on our mindset. And the thing that I found really fascinating is this: If I had spent my entire career in that industry, would I have challenged the ceiling, or would I have, accepted it, too? I don't know, but it's a question worth asking. So let's get into it. Whoop, whoop. There seems to be this assumption that if someone has successfully run a particular type of business, they must be the best person to coach other people running that business And I really wanna challenge that.
[00:03:48] Because being good at running a business
[00:03:51] and being good at coaching someone else to run a business are not necessarily the same skill. You think about it, some of the [00:04:00] world's best athletes have coaches who were never world champions themselves. Some were, some weren't. Those coaches still understood performance, they still understood behavior, and they understand preparation, strategy, psychology, discipline, and improvement.
[00:04:19] They know how to get the best out of someone, and that's their expertise. It's the same in business. I spent more than 20 years in HR and leadership. I've led teams. I've managed very complex organizational challenges. I've worked with commercial realities, developed leaders, and helped people improve their performance.
[00:04:43] I've worked inside large organizations where decisions have significant financial and human consequences, and I've built my own business. I guess there is that. But here's what I haven't done. I haven't run a law firm. I haven't run a creative agency. I haven't run a financial planning practice. I haven't run every single type of business that my clients operate.
[00:05:12] And thank goodness, because if that were the requirement, I'd have a very, very small client base. what I do understand is how businesses work. I understand people. I get leadership. I understand how to build teams and develop commercial discipline. I understand how to create accountability and make better decisions.
[00:05:35] And I understand that a business owner can be absolutely brilliant at their technical profession and still need support running the business that sits behind it. In fact, that's often exactly why they come to me. They don't need me to teach them their profession or their craft. They need me to help them build a better business around their profession, and that's a really important [00:06:00] distinction that I think we need to hold onto
[00:06:02] Here's where I want to push the conversation just a little further. I think one of the risks of working exclusively with people from your own industry is that you can end up with a very narrow view of what's possible. Not always, but sometimes. Imagine you're a lawyer for a minute. You've spent years working in law firms.
[00:06:25] You start your own practice, you join professional networks, and you spend time with other lawyers. And everyone talks about billable hours, utilization, how many clients they can manage, how many fee earners you need, and the challenges of running a practice. Now, all of that is very useful information, but what if your biggest business opportunity isn't about increasing billable hours?
[00:06:54] What if it's about redesigning your service offering totally, or changing your client mix, or developing, goodness gracious, fixed fee packages where appropriate? Or building a better referral strategy, or creating a business where you're not personally responsible for every single dollar of revenue.
[00:07:15] Someone who spent their entire career in that industry might absolutely see those opportunities,
[00:07:23] but someone outside the industry
[00:07:26] might ask questions
[00:07:27] that nobody else is asking.
[00:07:30] And that, that can be incredibly valuable. Let's take a marketing agency. Perhaps everyone you know says you need more staff to grow, right?
[00:07:39] Heard it all before. More clients, more staff. That's the equation. But what if the problem isn't your staffing? What if it's your pricing? What if it's the scope of work you're agreeing to? What if it's the type of clients you're attracting? What if your [00:08:00] business would be more profitable with fewer clients paying more for a better defined service?
[00:08:08] These are commercial questions, not industry specific questions, and sometimes the person who doesn't know the unwritten rules is the person who challenges them. They put that mirror up, and you don't always need someone who knows how everyone else does it. Sometimes you need someone who asks why you're doing it that way in the first place.
[00:08:33] And this is why I think the question, "Have you run a business exactly like mine?" can be the wrong question to ask a potential coach. Perhaps a better question is, "Have you helped business owners solve the problems that I'm facing?" Because if your problem is profitability, you need someone who understands profitability.
[00:08:57] If your problem is leadership, you need someone who understands leadership. And if your problem is business development, oh, I'm your girl. No, you need someone who understands how to generate and how to convert opportunities. And if your problem is that you're working 70 hours a week and can't take a holiday, you need someone who can help you build a business and a business model that doesn't rely entirely on you.
[00:09:27] Whether they've owned the same type of business, exactly the same type of business as you might be relevant, But it shouldn't automatically be the deciding factor. Now, let me tell you what I think a great business coach actually does. I think they help you think. They help you see what you can't see. They ask the questions that you're avoiding. They challenge your assumptions. They hold you accountable. You know that mirror?
[00:09:53] Mm, I know it's uncomfortable. And they help you turn good intentions into commercial outcomes. There's something else that I've [00:10:00] noticed over the years. Business owners are often very good at explaining why something won't work. You know the ones. We are brilliant at it. "Oh, our industry is different. Our clients are different.
[00:10:14] We're very unique. Our margins, oh yeah, you couldn't do that. Our market is very different." And sometimes, sometimes those things are true, credit where credit is due. But sometimes they're just very well-rehearsed explanations
[00:10:29] for why we haven't changed anything in 20 years. And I think a good coach needs to be able to say, "Hmm, show me.
[00:10:37] Show me the numbers. Show me the evidence. Show me what you've tried. Pull out your spreadsheet. Show me what's happened." Because I don't wanna build a coaching relationship around assumptions, I wanna build it around evidence and decisions and action. And here's something else that might surprise you. I don't need to be the smartest person in the room about my client's profession.
[00:11:05] I am no stale male pale. In fact, I don't wanna be. I want my clients to be brilliant at what they do. Hold that technical profession. I want them to know their clients, their industry, their craft, and their expertise inside and out. My job is to bring a different set of skills to the table, and when you put those two things together, that's where the magic happens, like a jigsaw.
[00:11:28] Their industry experience, my commercial experience, leadership, and business development experience, all like rolled into one. Two different perspectives working towards the same outcome. And then there's another benefit. Because I work across industries, I see things that someone working in just one industry might not see.
[00:11:50] I can take a brilliant idea from a consulting business and explore whether that actually might work in a professional services context. I [00:12:00] can take a client retention strategy from one business and adapt it to another. How cool is that? I can recognise a leadership problem in a business that the owner thinks is a sales problem.
[00:12:12] I can also spot patterns because I'm not looking through one industry lens, and that's really valuable for my clients. So let's be clear. An outside coach shouldn't pretend to know things that they don't know, and if there's a legal, clinical, technical, or regulatory question, we bring it to the appropriate expert.
[00:12:34] Good coaching isn't about knowing everything. I'm not an accountant, and I'm not a psychologist. But it's about knowing what you bring to the table, recognising what you don't, and making sure the business owner has access to the right expertise
[00:12:49] So here's what I'd love to change. Instead of asking a potential business coach, " Have you run a business exactly like mine before?" I would love you to ask, " Can you help me get from where I am to where I wanna be?" And then get specific. "What experience do you have solving the problems I'm facing? How do you approach profitability or revenue or business development?
[00:13:16] How do you challenge your clients? What happens when I don't do what I say I'm going to do? How will we measure progress? What happens when we disagree?" Because those are all the things that matter. And while we're at it, I think business coaches need to be a little bit more comfortable saying what they are and what they are not good at.
[00:13:42] I'm not the coach for everyone. I don't pretend to be. I'm particularly interested in established business owners who wanna make more money, mainly women, wanna improve their profitability, wanna build better teams, and create businesses that work for them, and I bring decades of experience [00:14:00] to that work.
[00:14:01] But I don't need to have owned every type of business to bring value to it. Just as a leadership coach doesn't need to have been the CEO of every organization their clients lead, or a financial advisor doesn't need to have personally experienced every financial situation that they advise on. Expertise can be transferable, and we need to stop undervaluing that
[00:14:27] So as we wrap, let me leave you with this. If you're looking for a business coach, please don't confuse familiarity with capability. Someone who knows your industry might be exactly what you need. Cool. They might have wonderful insights, brilliant connections, and actually very practical experience that could save you years of mistakes and a ton of money.
[00:14:52] Fantastic. But don't dismiss someone simply because they haven't walked your exact path, because the person who's walked your exact path might show you how to follow it, and the person who's walked a slightly different path might show you a way you didn't even know existed, and that could change everything.
[00:15:15] And for those of you who are sitting there thinking, "Well, in my industry, we can only make this much profit," I've got one question for you. Who told you that was your ceiling? And what if they're wrong? Until next time, go and make some money, go make some profit, and please go do some good in the world.
[00:15:36]