If you’re scared of sounding salesy, you’re probably leaving money on the table.
Your offer can be great, but if you stop the conversation too early, you’ll miss out on clients who were genuinely interested.
I’ve been deep in the weeds organising Day With The Queen. We’re talking 140–150 women, suppliers everywhere, venues, sponsors, printing, AV, activations, coffee, food, the whole circus. The details make the difference, which means I’ve had a lot of supplier conversations.
And here’s what shocked me: I can count on one hand the number of suppliers who actually followed me up.
I asked for info. I received proposals. Then… crickets. And I wasn’t uninterested; I was just busy.
I was running my business, coaching clients, travelling, organising multiple events and juggling the million moving parts that come with it. Their proposal didn’t disappear because I didn’t want it, but because my brain had about 84 tabs open.
This is where we get follow-up completely wrong. If you send a proposal, it’s not your potential client’s job to chase you. You’re the business owner. It’s your job to make the next move easy.
Why Silence Doesn’t Mean No
When someone doesn’t reply, most business owners write a whole story in their head.
They’re not interested. They thought it was too expensive. They changed their mind. They don’t like me. They went with someone else.
Maybe. Or maybe your email is sitting under an email about coffee carts. Maybe their kid got sick. Maybe they opened your proposal in the supermarket line and thought, “I need to reply to that,” and then life happened.
Silence is not a no. Silence is silence. Your job is to stop filling in the blanks for people and simply continue the conversation.
Follow-Up Isn’t Chasing
Badgering someone who has clearly said no is pushy. Ignoring boundaries is pushy. Messaging someone 14 times when they’ve never shown interest is pushy.
But following up after a real conversation, where they asked for details or said they were interested, is just you doing your job as the CEO. Sometimes it’s also just good manners.
Follow-up doesn’t have to sound like you’re tapping your foot waiting for a decision. It can sound like a human. Think of it as closing the loop.
The One-Sentence System That Makes Follow-Up Easy
Here’s the simplest system I use. At the bottom of every emailed proposal, I include one sentence:
“If I haven’t heard from you within a week, I shall follow you up.”
That sentence does two things. First, it tells them I’m going to follow up, so when I pop back into their inbox seven days later, it doesn’t feel pushy. I told them I was coming. Second, it puts me on the hook. I’ve said I’ll do it, so I put it in my diary and I follow through.
No guessing when to contact them or refreshing my inbox. No internal debate about whether I’m being annoying. Just business development.
What To Say When You Follow Up
The goal is not to sound like a robot. Follow-up should sound like you.
It can be light and breezy. It can be direct, it can be warm. It just needs to move the conversation forward.
Here are a few scripts you can steal and tweak:
- “Hey Sarah, popping this back to the top of your inbox. Did you get a chance to have a look?”
- “Hey Sarah, just circling back on the proposal. Is there anything holding you back that I can help you with or clarify?”
- “Hey Sarah, you mentioned you wanted a little time to think. Just checking back in as promised. Where did you land?”
- “Loved meeting you yesterday. I really enjoyed our conversation about [topic]. Would love to keep the conversation going.”
- “You told me to come back to you in September. Here I am. How are things looking at your end?”
- “I don’t want to keep filling your inbox, so I’m going to close the loop on this one for now. If the timing changes, you know where to find me.”
Notice what’s missing. No essays or apologies. No “sorry to bother you.” You’re not bothering them. You’re running a business.
Follow Up More Than Once
One follow-up is not enough. If someone has genuinely expressed interest, you can follow up multiple times. This is why we build it into our business development sprint.
Three reach outs, two follow-ups, one post. Simple. Because there is money sitting in your follow-up. So many women keep looking for new leads while ignoring the leads they already have.
Before you go chasing another hundred people, go back through your messages, emails, CRM, calendar and proposals you’ve already sent. Look at the people who said “not right now.” Look at the people who said “come back to me in September.”
If it’s September, go back.
Your Challenge
After this episode, I want you to do something immediately: find 10 people you’ve already had a conversation with. Not cold leads, but ten people who expressed interest. People who asked for info. People who went quiet. People who said “later.” People you met at an event who were curious.
Then follow them up. Keep it simple, ask the question, make the next step easy.
Sometimes the sale isn’t sitting in your next new lead. Sometimes it’s sitting in your follow-up.
For a copy of Emma’s book, ‘Go-getter: Raise your mojo, shift your mindset and thrive’ – https://emmamcqueen.com.au/want-more/emmas-book/
BD Sprint: